The Catholic Church has long been a beacon of hope and trust to its followers. The Church represents God, Faith and roots to be taught and handed down to generations. The Church, however has had a dark side for as long as it has exsisted.
In 1415 Czech theologian and philosopher Jan Hus was arrested by the Church, charged with heresy and burned at the stake. His actions that led to the charge of heresy? He believed and made his beliefs known, that since the Church was run by humans it was inherently flawed. Of course he was right and his words still ring true today.
I realize that 1415 was a different time that was not nearly as progressive as we are as a society today. That a man was willing to say what was true and was executed for it shows a level of arrogance and fear that never truly left the Church. That arrogance has been on full display within the structure of the Church throughout the current sexual abuse scandals. An arrogance that is unbecoming of any one person, much less the Church.
Betrayal
Arrogance has perpetuated the abuse and has victimized survivors over and over again. From cover ups to the transfers of known predators to the rule of pontifical secrecy. The Church has done more to protect itself than it has to protect its most vulnerable constituents.
When I consider the state of the Church today I think of Jan Hus. At the height of my anger against the Church for my abuse I held the organization to such extreme levels of holiness because that was how it was always presented to me. Eventually I had the realization that the Church, while enormous and divine was still just a worldly entity run by human beings and was therefore inherently flawed. Just as Jan Hus believed so long ago.
This isn’t an indictment of the Church per se. It is, however, an indictment of how the people running the Church have handled the clergy abuse scandal over the years. Decades of betrayal compounded by deceit and arrogance. Victims left to be victimized all over again by the organization that they believed in. The organization that gave their lives meaning and purpose and that has now damaged them irreparably. Predators enabled by humans to abuse again and again out of misplaced duty to the Church and not where their duty belonged, with the people of God who rely on it for spiritual guidance.
Changes
The Church, the connection to God through men and women of deity is as sacred to believers as God Himself. When the entity betrays its most vulnerable congregants and then refuses to accept full responsibility and in fact creates an environment for it to continue to victimize them, that connection is at best called into question and at worst shattered to pieces.
For the Church to take control of the situation and become, once again, a symbol of hope and trust it would have to first accept that it is inherently flawed. The Church, at it’s highest levels would have to not only denounce the acts of betrayal and criminal attacks on its constituents but take active measures to prevent it from ever happening again.
The Church would have to adopt a zero tolerance policy for any member of clergy or staff who is accused of even the slightest hint of sexual misconduct. Due process is important but any priest or other member of clergy who is accused of such misconduct must be removed from contact with the public immediately.
All previous cases of sexual abuse by priests and members of clergy should be fully investigated by an independent third party to determine if all actors involved in all cases have been removed form contact with the public. This means supervisors who knew and protected the predators. Peers who knew and did nothing to protect the public. Any person involved who did not take basic, appropriate steps to protect the congregations and hold the criminals responsible should be identified and removed from the Church at the very least and held criminally accountable when appropriate.
Going forward, strict guidelines must be put in place to protect the public. An organization as large as the Church cannot prevent predators from slipping through the cracks completely but it can put in place reviews and processes that will identify likely offenders in the ranks and deal with them appropriately. Mandatory reporting of suspicions and review boards to investigate reports would be the very bare minimum.
Additionally, there must be severe punishment for anyone who knowingly aids and abets predatory acts by members of clergy. There have been approximately 17,200 documented cases of sexual abuse by priests in the U.S. alone, most of which could have been prevented had the predators not been enabled to continue their reign of horrors on communities through cover up and protection by other members of clergy.
Pope Francis ushering in hope for change
Pope Francis has humbly ushered in an era of accountability that we haven’t seen from Church leadership before in regards to the scandal and has made significant changes in how abuse cases will be handled going forward.
The pope has said repeatedly that he takes personal responsibility for cases of abuse by members of the Church and calls the abuse a monstrosity. I find hope in his words denouncing the atrocities that have taken place and in that hope I pray for actionable steps to be put in place to prevent it from happening again. I pray also that the Church follows his lead in comforting those who have already suffered and provide guidance back to Faith for those who have lost it and seek a return to their Faith.
The pope’s stance on the abuses that have happened and the unconscionable cover up that has taken place gives me hope. He has been very vocal in his beliefs in interviews and writings. In December of 2016 Pope Francis penned a letter to his Bishops in which the following excerpt can be found.
On August 20, 2018 Pope Francis wrote a letter to the People of God calling on the Church to stand in solidarity with the victims of clerical sexual abuse. Several items in that letter stood out to me.
Apologies and action
As a survivor of clergy abuse I feel very emotional reading his words. Years ago I probably would have become angry reading them. I would have lashed out, claiming that words do nothing, action is needed. Today these words give me hope. Hope that the painstakingly slow process of change has begun. I have long yearned to hear words from the Church resembling this acknowledgment “Persons responsible for the protection of those children destroyed their dignity.”.
Apologies only mean so much and of course action means the most. The words in an apology tell me how sincere the apology actually is. These words tell me a lot. It is lazy to simply decry the actions of a man or woman. To say they acted out of sickness or some other issue, apologize and move on. It was very important for me to hear the acknowledgement of the failed responsibility of protection and the destroyed dignity, destroyed lives.
I have long stated that the Church is held to significantly higher standards of care than any one individual certainly, but even more than any other entity or organization. The people who make up the Church are representatives of God. Our Faith depends on devoted trust to their place in our lives. They are our connection to God and as such, we expect them to live trustworthy lives at the very least.
Hope
The broken trust, trust that was in my case blind as I am sure it is in most cases has been the hardest part of my recovery. Learning to trust fallible humans again has been painstakingly difficult. Learning trust the Church again seemed impossible to me. The hope I have been given through the words and actions of Pope Francis have given me the opportunity to learn to trust again. To trust people and to trust the Church.
Many people will say that he hasn’t done enough. While that is likely true, what he has done and is doing is more than has been done before. These things cannot change over night. Unfortunately, it’s a slow process to change the systematic cloak of protection that has been a part of the inner workings of the Church forever.
I am hopeful that the groundwork is being laid and that real change is on the horizon. When I get skeptical I remember that acknowledgment of the problem is the first step needed for change. This pope has acknowledged what has happened deeply and repeatedly. He has also claimed personal responsibility for the actions of the perpetrators. He has also vowed to begin the process of creating a system that will not allow it to ever happen again.
Pope Francis is quoted as saying “…even one case of abuse in the Church is a monstrosity…”. He’s right and striving to completely eradicate abuse from the Church is the only way to move forward. I hope I can find a place in the process of making these changes.
More from the August 18, 2020 letter from Pope Francis to the People of God
Am I my brother’s keeper?
I think his inclusion of Genesis 4:9 is significant. I certainly do not believe that the predators who worked their way into the Church and used their places in society to exact horrific traumas on the youngest and most vulnerable people in the congregations deserve any leniency at all. They are the root problem as they are the ones who committed such disgusting and unconscionable acts.
However, if not for the enabling and protection by other members of the clergy the overall enormity of the scandal could have been lessened. Had they adhered to the words of Cain in Genesis 4:9. “Am I my brother’s keeper?” countless people could have been protected if they had simply considered where their responsibility truly rested. The answer would have to have been a resounding yes and those predators would have been stopped. The scandal would have been minimized, the damage done to the Church lessened and most importantly, the lives of innocent children and vulnerable adults would have been preserved.
The future of the Church and the trust which it garners from the people depends on Genesis 4:9. The people who need protecting are the people of God, the flock, the followers looking to the Church for spiritual guidance. When everyone in the Church understands this and adheres to it, people will begin to trust again.
Writing is healing. One Love.